Tag Archives: withdrawal

More on HMRC’s latest APN mass withdrawal

IMG_20160507_200809From Tax Journal:

“(…) One of the grounds of challenge was that condition C (in FA 2014 s 219(4)) was not met. Condition C is that, amongst other things, the chosen arrangements are ‘DOTAS arrangements’. Section 219(5) defines DOTAS arrangements as meaning ‘notifiable arrangements’ which have been allocated a scheme reference number. In other words, the arrangements must be notifiable under the DOTAS regime, as a matter of law. The fact that the arrangements were notified to HMRC is irrelevant for the purposes of ascertaining whether condition C has been satisfied.
HMRC took some six months to consider this ground of challenge before finally accepting that the arrangements were not notifiable under the DOTAS regime and that the APNs would therefore be withdrawn (…)
HMRC may have to accept this ground of challenge in relation to other similar EBT arrangements as it is obliged to be consistent in its approach and to treat all taxpayers in a similar position in the same way. “