Private Eye nails it again

From Private Eye No. 1433, 9 December – 22 December 2016, page 6 News:

Infernal Revenue

“Last week’s report from parliament’s public accounts committee on HM Revenue & Customs read like a compendium of old Eye stories.

From the disastrous Concentrix tax credits affair (a “complete failure”, with “many claimants being wrongly accused of fraudulent claims” and causing “unnecessary hardship and suffering”) to misleading claims about success investigating tax dodging, the MPs’ message was unrelentingly critical.

But on one point they were wrong. “HMRC’s senior management cannot afford to be complacent about the catastrophic collapse in customer service in 2014/15 and the first half of 2015/16,” said committee chair Meg Hillier MP. The trouble is they can afford to be complacent. The price of failure is simply gratitude from government for mercilessly implementing cuts without care for the consequences.

The HMRC chief executive who presided over the Concentrix and other customer service “catastrophes”, Lin Homer, bagged a damehood earlier this year. Meanwhile, the non-executive chairman of the HMRC board since 2012, Ian Barlow, remains at the head of the boardroom table. Even the minister responsible for the tax system throughout the years that gave the country these disasters, David Gauke, was recently promoted to the cabinet as chief secretary to the Treasury. A similar performance elsewhere would have meant political oblivion. But HMRC’s cock-ups tend to hit lower-income families whose plight can be safely ignored, giving plenty of room for complancency.